Hague court lifts order on BYD records seized by JLR in Ti7 Defender dispute

JLR must destroy digital records taken from BYD's Dutch offices, but the ruling does not decide whether BYD's seven-seat Ti7 plug-in hybrid SUV infringes Land Rover Defender rights. That question is expected to go to separate proceedings, while the Ti7 is due in UK showrooms in November.

THRIVE Newsdesk · Market & BusinessPublished
Hague court lifts order on BYD records seized by JLR in Ti7 Defender dispute
THRIVE illustration

A district court in The Hague has lifted an earlier order covering information collected from BYD's operations in Schiedam and Hoofddorp, and has instructed Jaguar Land Rover to destroy the material within 24 hours of the judgment being served, Fleet News reports. The ruling does not determine whether the Ti7 infringes JLR's design rights, copyright or other intellectual property.

Court-appointed bailiffs acting for JLR seized digital records from the two BYD offices in August. JLR's legal action centres on its allegation that BYD's new Ti7 SUV infringes intellectual property rights associated with the Land Rover Defender.

If JLR fails to comply, it could face penalties of €50,000 (£41k) an hour, capped at €500,000 (£417k). The ruling also prevents JLR from taking further enforcement action under the original seizure authorisation.

Advertisement

The court found that JLR did not need the seized information to pursue its design claim. It also concluded that the records were unnecessary for assessing potential damages, because BYD has not yet sold the Ti7 in the EU.

JLR chief executive PB Balaji gave a different explanation in a call to journalists. He said the files were no longer needed because BYD has now announced sales plans for the Ti7 in Europe. "Our vehicles are getting built on decades of heritage, engineering, excellence and, of course, the capability and the craftsmanship that these cars execute. Therefore we will do what it takes to protect them," he said.

The infringement allegations themselves are expected to be considered in separate proceedings in The Hague and Rotterdam.

The Ti7 is a seven-seat plug-in hybrid SUV that is already sold in China under BYD's Fangchengbao brand. According to Fleet News, it should reach UK showrooms in November, with customer deliveries beginning in January. Its expected starting price of £47,995 would put it more than £20,000 below some versions of the Defender.

JLR has gone to court over the Defender's design before. In 2020 it was unsuccessful in a legal case to stop Ineos selling the Grenadier on the grounds that it was too close to the original Defender.

Sources

Fleet News

How THRIVE sources and checks its stories · Corrections, and how to report an error

The Tuesday briefing

The week's fleet numbers and news, every Tuesday morning. Free.

One email a week. Unsubscribe in a click.

Named in this story? You have a right of reply: email hello@thrivefleet.co.uk and a challenged claim will be marked under review while we check it.

Got a story, or a question about this one? Contact the newsroom. We read everything that comes in. With the volume of fleet news, not everything can run, but a story with a number, a date or a decision in it stands a good chance.